Secondary Causes « go round in circles »

Typically, secondary causes “run in circles”: for example, heat comes from combustion, which requires oxygen produced by plants through photosynthesis, itself dependent on sunlight and chlorophyll, and so on. The chain of secondary causes must ultimately lead to a first cause that is its own cause. This corresponds to the Greek anankê stênai — “it is necessary to stop” (Aristotle, Metaphysics, II, 994b; XII, 1070a).

The doctrine of the efficacy of secondary causes is central in metaphysics, since it demonstrates that the dependence of beings upon a transcendent first cause does not deprive them of causal efficacy but, on the contrary, grounds and justifies it (Thomas Aquinas, 13th c.). On the ontological level, the efficacy of beings manifests itself through the four kinds of cause: material, formal, efficient, and final. On the theological level, creatures act because of what God is: first cause, pure intelligence and pure will, and hence cause of the very causality of secondary causes.

In a cosmological perspective, secondary causes constitute the intelligible fabric of the created universe. They never operate in isolation; their efficacy unfolds within a hierarchical network where each level of reality depends on a higher one. To say that God is first cause is not to deny natural autonomy, but to affirm that intelligibility itself presupposes a supreme principle.

Traditional Thomism insists that the first cause acts in and through secondary causes without replacing them. God is not a rival agent among others, but the principle of being. This doctrine avoids both deism (God as absent watchmaker) and fideism (denying creaturely agency). Secondary causes safeguard the genuine dignity of creation: creatures truly act because God truly grounds their power to act.

Further reading: